Best Propane Lanterns Reviewed – Don’t get stuck with the wrong lantern!

Many people choose camping propane as the energy source for campsite illumination.

Don’t get stuck with the wrong lantern!

We’ve reviewed many different models to help you choose the best propane lantern for your camping requirements.

Best Propane Lanterns Reviewed by CampingForFoodies features a propane camping lantern softly lit against a deep blue night sky at a campsite with text over image reading best propane lantern.

Psst we’re compensated…see our disclosures.

Best Gas Lantern For Camping

  • Our top picks for the best propane lantern for camping in each category are:

OUR PICK FOR BRIGHTEST: Coleman Northstar Propane LanternOUR PICK FOR BRIGHTEST: Coleman Northstar Propane LanternOUR PICK FOR BRIGHTEST: Coleman Northstar Propane LanternOUR PICK FOR EASIEST TO TRANSPORT: Coleman QuickPack Deluxe Propane LanternOUR PICK FOR EASIEST TO TRANSPORT: Coleman QuickPack Deluxe Propane LanternOUR PICK FOR EASIEST TO TRANSPORT: Coleman QuickPack Deluxe Propane LanternOUR PICK FOR BEST BANG FOR THE BUCK: Stansport 2 Mantle Propane LanternOUR PICK FOR BEST BANG FOR THE BUCK: Stansport 2 Mantle Propane LanternOUR PICK FOR BEST BANG FOR THE BUCK: Stansport 2 Mantle Propane LanternOUR PICK FOR MOST COMPACT: Coleman Gas Lantern 1 Mantle Propane LanternOUR PICK FOR MOST COMPACT: Coleman Gas Lantern 1 Mantle Propane LanternOUR PICK FOR MOST COMPACT: Coleman Gas Lantern 1 Mantle Propane Lantern

 


Propane Camping Lanterns Reviewed

You want a portable camping lantern to create as much light as possible but the brightness level is not the only thing to consider when choosing a lantern.

We have reviewed different models of propane tank lanterns and grouped them according to their maximum lumen outputs.


Lanterns With 1500 Lumens

1540 lumens – Coleman Northstar Propane Lantern

Our top pick for BRIGHTEST PROPANE CAMPING LANTERN

Coleman Northstar Propane LanternColeman Northstar Propane LanternColeman Northstar Propane Lantern

 

PROS:

This is the brightest of the propane camping lanterns we
reviewed with up to 1540 lumens.

The base provides stability to the lantern when you are
using it and folds for easier storage.

It runs on a 16.4-oz. propane cylinder for approximately 4 hours on the brightest setting and 9 hours on low. (NOTE: if you run out, here’s how to refill 1 pound propane tanks with a propane refill adapter.)

The metal guard protects the high-temperature globe.

It features InstaStart ignition for lighting without
matches.

Of all of the mantels, this lantern uses Insta-Clip tube mantles which are the easiest to install.

CONS:

This lantern works best on the brighter settings … when you try to dim the output, the lantern may not stay lit because the regulator is quite sensitive.

The push button ignition is convenient but may be inconsistent so you may need matches on some occasions.

When this lantern is on the lower settings it tends to emit a loud whistling noise.


1500 lumens – Coleman Deluxe PerfectFlow Propane Lantern With Hard Carry Case

Coleman Deluxe PerfectFlow Propane Lantern With Hard Carry CaseColeman Deluxe PerfectFlow Propane Lantern With Hard Carry CaseColeman Deluxe PerfectFlow Propane Lantern With Hard Carry Case

 

PROS:

The carrying case protects this lantern during transportation
and storage.

As one of the brightest propane camping lanterns, this model
produces up to 1500 lumens on high and casts light up to 85 feet.

You can get approximately 4 hours out of a 1lb propane
cylinder when operating this lantern on high and about 9 hours on the low setting.

It features matchless lighting with its push button
ignition.

It has a high-temperature tolerance glass globe and has a metal
guard for additional protection.

The base is steady and its feet collapse for more convenient
transportation and storage.

CONS:

The push-button igniter may not be consistent so you’ll want
to carry matches as a backup.

This lantern is a bit louder than most comparable models no matter if you are operating it on a high or low setting.


Lanterns With 1000 Lumens

Coleman Elite Perfectflow Propane LanternColeman Elite Perfectflow Propane LanternColeman Elite Perfectflow Propane Lantern

 

PROS:

This lantern produces up to 1000 lumens of light that reaches up to 75 feet away.

As a way to combat varying weather and altitudes, this lantern is designed with a PerfectFlow system producing consistent light output no matter where you are camping.

A 16.4-oz. propane cylinder runs it for approximately 8
hours.

It has a matchless ignition starter.

CONS:

As with other matchless lanterns, this push-button igniter
is intermittent so you’ll want to have matches in case you need them.

On the low setting, this lantern may emit a loud whistling sound.


1000 lumens – Coleman Gas Lantern | 1000 Lumens Deluxe Propane Lantern

Coleman Gas Lantern | 1000 Lumens Deluxe Propane LanternColeman Gas Lantern | 1000 Lumens Deluxe Propane LanternColeman Gas Lantern | 1000 Lumens Deluxe Propane Lantern

 

PROS:

This propane gas lantern creates up to 1000 lumens that cast
light up to 75 feet away.

You’ll get approximately 7 hours out of a 1 pound propane cylinder when operating it on high.

The glass globe is tolerant of high-temperatures to prevent
cracking.

Its collapsible footed base makes storage convenient.

CONS:

The control knob may have a tendency to “drift” between different settings making it a bit more difficult to regulate.

Matches are required to light this lantern but because the lanterns with push-button ignition are typically intermittent, we don’t consider this a big drawback.


Our top pick for Easiest To Transport Camping Propane Lantern

Coleman QuickPack Deluxe Propane LanternColeman QuickPack Deluxe Propane LanternColeman QuickPack Deluxe Propane LanternColeman QuickPack Deluxe Propane LanternColeman QuickPack Deluxe Propane LanternColeman QuickPack Deluxe Propane Lantern

 

PROS:

This lantern produces up to 1000 lumens and lasts approximately
13 hours on one 16 oz. propane tank.

It features one of the most compact carrying cases making it
easy to transport and protect the glass.

It features PerfectFlow technology that is designed to create a steady stream of fuel in all weather
conditions.

Its wide base makes it very stable and also acts as the
bottom of the carrying case.

CONS:

This lantern does not have push button ignition so matches
are required but because the push button styles are not always consistent, we
don’t consider this to be a big disadvantage.

The base does not actually “attach” to the can of propane so
when you pick the lantern up by the handle, the base may remain on the table
(or wherever you have it setting.)

The knob may have a tendency to “wander” to other brightness
levels.

On the lower settings, this lantern may inadvertently go out.


Coleman Two-Mantle Propane Lantern With CaseColeman Two-Mantle Propane Lantern With CaseColeman Two-Mantle Propane Lantern With Case

 

PROS:

This lantern produces up to 1000 lumens and lasts up to
approximately 14 hours on a 1 pound propane camping cylinder.

Its carrying case opens widely so loading the lantern is
simple.

It has a stable base with retractable feet.

CONS:

Matches are required to light this lantern but we don’t
consider this a big drawback because the push-button styles can be sporadic.

The soft aluminum header makes inadvertent cross threading possible.


Lanterns With Under 1000 Lumens

810 lumens – Coleman Two Mantle InstaStart QuickPack Lantern

Our top pick for Best Bang For The Buck Propane Camping Lantern

Stansport 2 Mantle Propane LanternStansport 2 Mantle Propane LanternStansport 2 Mantle Propane Lantern

 

PROS:

This lantern produces up to 810 lumens and runs off of a
standard 1-pound propane tank.

Its “Dura Base” features tip-resistant feet.

This is one of the most inexpensive propane camping lanterns
that has 2 mantles.

CONS:

The base is not “connected” to the propane tank and may not
stay on if you pick it up by the handle.

Matches are required to light this lantern but we don’t consider this a big weakness because the push-button styles can be random.


300 lumens – Coleman Gas Lantern | 300 Lumens Compact 1 Mantle Propane Lantern

Our top pick for Most Compact Propane Lantern

Coleman Gas Lantern | 300 Lumens Compact 1 Mantle Propane LanternColeman Gas Lantern | 300 Lumens Compact 1 Mantle Propane LanternColeman Gas Lantern | 300 Lumens Compact 1 Mantle Propane Lantern

 

PROS:

This Coleman compact propane lantern is small but mighty, it
produces 300 lumens with a single mantle.

A 16oz propane cylinder will run this lantern up to
approximately 11 hours.

There is a metal guard surrounding the globe to protect it
from impacts.

Most lanterns have a wire handle but this one uses a chain
making it more compact.

It requires only 1 mantle.

CONS:

300 lumens may not be bright enough for all applications.

It may be easy to accidentally tear the mantle when you are putting it on the lantern because of its location/design.

You need matches to light this lantern but we don’t consider this a big limitation because the push-button styles can be hit-or-miss.


Propane Lantern Stands

You can set your lantern on the ground, on a table or hang it from a tree.

If you don’t have a good location for your lantern to provide light in a specific area, a Propane Lantern Stand is a great option.

Coleman Lantern StandColeman Lantern StandColeman Lantern Stand

 


Alternative Lanterns With Mantles

Coleman Premium 700 Lumens Dual-Fuel Camping Lantern With CaseColeman Premium 700 Lumens Dual-Fuel Camping Lantern With CaseColeman Premium 700 Lumens Dual-Fuel Camping Lantern With Case

 

Some people like the brightness that comes from mantles but want options other than propane.

This Coleman Premium 700 Lumens Dual-Fuel Camping Lantern uses Coleman Liquid Fuel or unleaded gasoline which provides better performance in frigid conditions.


Replacing Mantles On Propane Lanterns

If you have never replaced a mantle before, this video shows you how to replace the mantles on a Coleman lantern.


If you use larger propane tanks to fill your smaller ones, you may want to check out the service offered through Costco propane refill.

The prices are very competitive but the service is not available at all Costco stores … we have a video with tips on how to use the service and find store locations near you.

Costco Propane Refill How To Use The Costco Propane Service by CampingForFoodies features a class A motorhome RV parked at a Costco propane refill station with an employee getting ready to fill a portable propane tank from a large stationary tank that has warning and no smoking signs on it, text over the image reads Costco propane refill, how to get propane at Costco, membership is required.

Other Camp Lighting Options

Propane lanterns are just one lighting style.

You may want to consider solar and battery powered camping lights too.

Lighting Your Campsite With The Best Camping Lights - Camping For Foodies .com

More Camping Gear Reviews

If you love the idea of using propane as fuel at your campsite, check out the best propane camping gear that will help you cook, stay warm and more!

Best Propane Camping Gear Reviewed by CampingForFoodies

Looking for other types of gadgets that make camping easy and fun?

Check out the best camping gear before you make your next purchase.

Best Camping Gear For Tent And RV Camping by CampingForFoodies

Our Cool Camping Products Make Great Gifts!


Similar Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *